• Email Us: [email protected]
  • Contact Us: +1 718 874 1545
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Medical Market Report

  • Home
  • All Reports
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Clay Cylinders May Rewrite The Timeline On The Origins Of The Alphabet

November 22, 2024 by Deborah Bloomfield

The transition from symbols like hieroglyphics to writing may have happened much earlier than had been thought, an archaeologist has claimed. However, if the evidence stands up to scrutiny, it poses the question of why one of humanity’s greatest inventions appears to have taken so long to gain widespread use.

There’s probably no way to settle the question of which of humanity’s technological innovations was most important, but writing has to be a contender. The capacity to store and transmit information accelerated the spread of everything that came afterwards, as well as allowing new developments that would have been unlikely or impossible before.

Advertisement

However, writing might be more fairly considered to be two major advances: pictograms like hieroglyphics, followed by the development of the alphabet thousands of years later. However, the gap between the two may not have been quite as large as we thought, based on the contents of a 4,400-year-old Syrian tomb.

“Alphabets revolutionized writing by making it accessible to people beyond royalty and the socially elite. Alphabetic writing changed the way people lived, how they thought, how they communicated,” said Professor Glenn Schwartz of Johns Hopkins University in a statement. 

It was thought that this innovation took place around 1900 BCE. Examples of alphabetic scripts appear first in Egypt around that time. However, in 2004 Schwartz was part of a team conducting a dig at Tell Umm-el Marra, an ancient city in western Syria that he suspects, but has not yet proven, is the city referred to as Tuba in ancient records. Schwartz believes Umm-el Marra was founded around 2700 BCE.

Many things have become dangerous in Syria over the last 20 years, archaeology included, so follow-up at the site has been limited. Before the war, however, tombs from the Early Bronze Age around 300 years after the city was founded revealed exceptional treasures, providing gold and silver jewelry somehow escaped grave robbers for millennia. Modern historians may place an even higher value on pottery vessels and cookware, but beside the pots Schwartz found something he now thinks has greater significance still. 

Advertisement

Four lightly baked clay cylinders the size of fingers have markings on them that Schwartz told The American Society for Overseas Research’s Annual Conference appear to be a form of alphabetic writing. Yet carbon-14 dating of the tomb itself and some of its contents indicate these were made 500 years before the oldest previous such writing we know.

“The cylinders were perforated, so I’m imagining a string tethering them to another object to act as a label. Maybe they detail the contents of a vessel, or maybe where the vessel came from, or who it belonged to,” Schwartz said. “Without a means to translate the writing, we can only speculate.”

Schwartz has previously published two analyses of the cylinders, which tentatively raised the idea these were predecessor of the alphabet, but now appears to be making the case with more confidence.

Even if the dating is right, Schwartz’s case may be disputed on the grounds that the markings’ resemblance to an alphabet is a coincidence. There are only 12 symbols on the cylinders and one of them looks more like a hieroglyph than a letter. The muted response to Schwartz’s previous work suggests he has yet to convince most of his peers.

Advertisement

“Previously, scholars thought the alphabet was invented in or around Egypt sometime after 1900 BCE,” Schwartz said. “But our artifacts are older and from a different area on the map, suggesting the alphabet may have had an entirely different origin story than we thought.”



If Schwartz’s claims are accepted, they raise the question of whether this early script represents a sort of ancestor of the Egyptian alphabet, or if it formed a sort of dead end? Either answer would require further explanation. Why would such a useful innovation not survive, if it didn’t, only to be reinvented centuries later? Was there something about this script that made this initial effort at alphabetic writing less user-friendly than the one that conquered the world, and therefore caused it to be abandoned?

Alternatively, if our modern alphabet has roots 500 years further back in time, why have we not found examples of it in between? Syria and Egypt are not that far apart, but one might still expect to see some signs of an innovation’s journey.

Advertisement

Cylinders played a big part in the development of writing. Coincidentally, earlier this month another cylinder was proposed to represent evidence for how one of the most important pre-alphabetic forms of writing developed. For centuries before the alphabet, cuneiform pictograms represented the written language of Mesopotamia and surrounds. According to a paper in Antiquity, a stone cylinder dating from Uruk in around 3000 BCE shows how stones engraved with symbols were rolled onto clay tablets to leave stamped impressions. This cylinder provides the first direct evidence for a link between these seals and proto-cuniform’s development.

Schwartz’s previous work on the cylinders’ markings are published in a book, Opening the Tablet Box, and open access in Pasiphae.

Deborah Bloomfield
Deborah Bloomfield

Related posts:

  1. Cricket-Manchester test likely to be postponed after India COVID-19 case
  2. EU to attend U.S. trade meeting put in doubt by French anger
  3. Soccer-West Ham win again, Leicester and Napoli falter
  4. Lacking Company, A Dolphin In The Baltic Is Talking To Himself

Source Link: Clay Cylinders May Rewrite The Timeline On The Origins Of The Alphabet

Filed Under: News

Primary Sidebar

  • The Oldest Stalagmite Ever Dated Was Found In Oklahoma Rocks, Dating Back 289 Million Years
  • 2024’s Great American Eclipse Made Some Birds Behave In Surprising Ways, But Not All Were Fooled
  • “Carter Catastrophe”: The Math Equation That Predicts The End Of Humanity
  • Why Is There No Nobel Prize For Mathematics?
  • These Are The Only Animals Known To Incubate Eggs In Their Stomachs And Give “Birth” Out Their Mouths
  • Constipated? This One Fruit Could Help, Says First-Ever Evidence-Led Diet Guidance
  • NGC 2775: This Galaxy Breaks The Rules Of “Galactic Evolution” And Baffles Astronomers
  • Meet The “Four-Eyed” Hirola, The World’s Most Endangered Antelope With Fewer Than 500 Left
  • The Bizarre 1997 Experiment That Made A Frog Levitate
  • There’s A Very Good Reason Why October 1582 On Your Phone Is Missing 10 Days
  • Skynet-1A: Military Spacecraft Launched 56 Years Ago Has Been Moved By Persons Unknown
  • There’s A Simple Solution To Helping Avoid Erectile Dysfunction (But You’re Not Going To Like It)
  • Interstellar Object 3I/ATLAS May Be 10 Billion Years Old, This Rare Spider Is Half-Female, Half-Male Split Down The Middle, And Much More This Week
  • Why Do Trains Not Have Seatbelts? It’s Probably Not What You Think
  • World’s Driest Hot Desert Just Burst Into A Rare And Fleeting Desert Bloom
  • Theoretical Dark Matter Infernos Could Melt The Earth’s Core, Turning It Liquid
  • North America’s Largest Mammal Once Numbered 60 Million – Then Humans Nearly Drove It To Extinction
  • North America’s Largest Ever Land Animal Was A 21-Meter-Long Titan
  • A Two-Headed Fossil, 50/50 Spider, And World-First Butt Drag
  • Interstellar Comet 3I/ATLAS Is Losing Buckets Of Water Every Second – And It’s Got Cyanide
  • Business
  • Health
  • News
  • Science
  • Technology
  • +1 718 874 1545
  • +91 78878 22626
  • [email protected]
Office Address
Prudour Pvt. Ltd. 420 Lexington Avenue Suite 300 New York City, NY 10170.

Powered by Prudour Network

Copyrights © 2025 · Medical Market Report. All Rights Reserved.

Go to mobile version