• Email Us: [email protected]
  • Contact Us: +1 718 874 1545
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Medical Market Report

  • Home
  • All Reports
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Fish Suffer “10 Minutes Of Intense Pain” Before Dying In Commercial Fishing Operations

June 11, 2025 by Deborah Bloomfield

We’re sorry to say this is a sad and unpleasant one. A new study has shown the hidden world of pain fish endure before they die after being caught. In some instances, the animals can suffer high levels of pain for up to 10 minutes, a situation that experts say needs greater regulation to improve their overall welfare.

The study focused on the experience of rainbow trout and provides a quantified measurement of pain caused by air asphyxia, a common slaughter method used to kill trout and other fish. The team provided this pain index using the innovative Welfare Footprint Framework (WFF), developed by the Center for Welfare Metrics, to assess the total time animals spend suffering or in well-being.

Fish make up an important portion of many people’s diets. Across the world, 2.2 trillion wild and 171 billion farmed fish are killed each year for this purpose. That’s a lot of fish. To put it into perspective, 2.2 trillion fish per year is equivalent to nearly 70,000 fish killed per second – or if fish were football fans, it’s the equivalent of killing an entire stadium’s crowd every second. And that’s just the wild fish being slaughtered!

There is now growing societal concern about the impacts production practices have on animal welfare, especially within sustainability assessments. In short, environmental gains are deemed unjustifiable if they occur at the expense of animal welfare. However, for a long time we have lacked a way to quantify animal suffering or their well-being; and yet efforts to improve animal welfare depend on our ability to compare how different policies and practices will impact them by way of a common metric.

This is where the WFF comes in. It allows us to assign time-based values to subjective experiences, even those of animals that cannot express pain in a way we would understand it. 

“Similar to life cycle analysis, the WFF begins by defining the scope of analysis, followed by an inventory of relevant circumstances (e.g., handling procedures, housing, density, air/water quality) and their biological outcomes (e.g., injuries, diseases, deprivations) over a timeframe of interest,” the authors write in their paper. “The impact of these biological outcomes on welfare is evaluated by estimating the intensity and duration of each resulting affective experience (e.g., physical pain, fear, or joy), using existing evidence from multiple research lines.”

So by quantifying the total time animals spend in either a negative or positive experiential state of differing intensities, the WFF can offer a comparable and relatable metric that can be used for different species and different scenarios.

“The [WFF] provides a rigorous and transparent evidence-based approach to measuring animal welfare, and enables informed decisions about where to allocate resources for the greatest impact,” Dr Wladimir Alonso, who came up with the method, explained in a statement.

How much do fish suffer?

In this context, the study found that rainbow trout endure an average of 10 minutes of intense pain during air asphyxia, with an estimated range of between two and 22 minutes of pain depending on factors like fish size or water temperature. This is effectively 24 minutes of pain per kilogram of fish.

The study also assessed the cost-effectiveness of interventions such as electrical stunning. If implemented properly, this alternative way to kill fish could avert 60 to 1,200 minutes of moderate to extreme pain for every US dollar of capital costs. Alternatively, percussive stunning offers high welfare potential, but is still challenging to implement consistently in commercial settings. Worryingly, the assessment also shows that pre-slaughter activities like crowding and transporting fish, which are often overlooked, likely cause greater cumulative suffering than the slaughter itself.

These results could help inform and shape new regulatory discussions as well as improving certification standards across the world. They could also guide welfare investments that deliver the greatest benefits for the cost. 

The study is published in Scientific Reports.

Deborah Bloomfield
Deborah Bloomfield

Related posts:

  1. As U.S. unemployment benefits end, firms hope for a wave of applicants
  2. Google’s R&D division experiments with newsletters powered by Google Drive
  3. Twitter Says It Is No Longer Stopping Any COVID-19 Misinformation
  4. Sapphires Are Cooked Up By Volcanic Fury – And Now We Know How

Source Link: Fish Suffer "10 Minutes Of Intense Pain" Before Dying In Commercial Fishing Operations

Filed Under: News

Primary Sidebar

  • Man Broke Down Wall In His Basement And Discovered An Ancient Underground City That Once Housed 20,000 People
  • Same-Sex Penguin Couple Adopt And Raise Chick – And They’ve All Got 10/10 Names
  • Dolphins May Not “See” With Echolocation, But Instead “Feel” With It
  • Confirmed! Comet 3I/ATLAS Is Indeed An Interstellar Visitor, Quite Different From Its Predecessors
  • At 192, Jonathan – The Oldest Living Land Animal – Has Lived Through 40 US Presidents
  • 300,000-Year-Old Wooden Tools “Made By Denisovans” Discovered In China
  • Why Do Cats Eyes Glow? For The Same Reason Great White Sharks’ Do, Silly
  • G-astronomical News: Michelin-Starred Meal To Be Served On The ISS
  • In 2032, Earth May Witness A Once-In-5,000-Year Event On The Moon
  • Brand New Microscope Designed For Underwater Reveals Stunning Details Of Corals
  • The Atlantic’s Major Circulation Current Is Showing Worrying Signs, But Is Collapse Near?
  • “The Rings Held The Answer”: How We Finally Figured Out Saturn’s Day Length In 2019
  • Mystery Of Leonardo Da Vinci’s “Vitruvian Man” Solved By A Dentist And A Protractor
  • Asteroid Ryugu’s Latest Mineral Is As Weird As Finding “A Tropical Seed In The Arctic”
  • IFLScience The Big Questions: Are We Living Through A Sixth Mass Extinction?
  • Alien Abduction Or A Trick Of The Mind? A Down To Earth Explanation Of Close Encounters
  • Six Months Into Trump’s Presidency, Americans Report Record Low Pride In Being American
  • TikToker Unknowingly Handles Extremely Venomous Cone Snail And Lives To Tell The Tale
  • Scientists Sequence Oldest Egyptian DNA To Date, From A Whopping 4,800 Years Ago
  • “Uncharted Waters”: Large Hadron Collider Begins Colliding Oxygen For The First Time
  • Business
  • Health
  • News
  • Science
  • Technology
  • +1 718 874 1545
  • +91 78878 22626
  • [email protected]
Office Address
Prudour Pvt. Ltd. 420 Lexington Avenue Suite 300 New York City, NY 10170.

Powered by Prudour Network

Copyrights © 2025 · Medical Market Report. All Rights Reserved.

Go to mobile version