• Email Us: [email protected]
  • Contact Us: +1 718 874 1545
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Medical Market Report

  • Home
  • All Reports
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Ig Nobel Prizewinner Debunks Supposed “Blue Zones”, Where People Live Exceptionally Long Lives

September 24, 2024 by Deborah Bloomfield

Do people in supposed “blue zones” really have an above-average chance of living over 100 years? Despite the idea’s popularity, new Ig Nobel award-winning research has kind of killed it (pun most certainly intended). It seems past research into extreme old-age demographics has been riddled with fundamental flaws that have produced distorted conclusions.

Advertisement

The Ig Nobel Prize is a satirical annual award handed out scientific research that “makes people laugh, and then think”. The award first started in 1991 and is intended to celebrate the unusual and imaginative approaches some researchers adopt for their subject.

This year, Dr Saul Justin Newman at the Centre for Longitudinal Studies, UCL, won the first-ever Ig Nobel award for Demography for his work on data about the world’s oldest people. According to his findings, patterns concerning extremely old age and supercentenarians (people of 110 years of age or older) are likely the result of poor record-keeping, clerical errors, and pension fraud.

In doing so, Newman has struck a significant blow to the popular idea concerning so-called “blue zones”. These are places in the world that appear to have unusually high concentrations of extremely old people living within them. Examples of proposed blue zones include Loma Linda, in California, Okinawa in Japan, Sardinia in Italy, Nicoya in Costa Rica, and Ikaria in Greece.

The popularity of the idea that there are some places with exceptional longevity has sparked significant interest, leading to diverse efforts to understand how so many people are living so much longer than average. The overall populations within these blue zones, as well as those individuals who appear to be living into extreme old age, have been analyzed for their life patterns, social connections, biomarkers, genomic variations and so on. All of these studies are searching for the same answer: what are the secrets to long life?

Advertisement

But Newman believes the answer has less to do with any particular lifestyle factor, and rather more to do with dodgy data.

In his new preprint study, yet to be published in a peer-reviewed journal, Newman shows that the highest rates of achieving old age are predicted by three factors: high poverty, a lack of birth certificates, and fewer 90-year-olds.

Poverty, in this context, leads to greater pressure to commit pension fraud. At the same time, the state-specific introduction of birth certificates, Newman claims, is associated with a 69 to 82 percent decrease in the number of supercentenarian records.

This work even challenges supposedly validated cases of the world’s oldest people, including the world’s oldest man, who appears to have three different birthdays.

Advertisement

“Substantial error rates were recently uncovered in every ‘Blue Zone’,” Newman writes.

“In 1997, thirty thousand Italian citizens were discovered to be claiming the pension whilst dead. In 2008, 42 percent of Costa Rican 99+ year olds were revealed to have ‘mis-stated’ their age in the 2000 census and, after limited error-correction, the Nicoya Blue Zone shrunk by around 90 percent and old-age life expectancy plummeted from world-leading to ‘near the bottom of the pack’.”

In 2010, over 230,000 Japanese centenarians were found to be missing, imagined, the results of clerical errors, or actually dead.

Even an analysis of the supposed reasons for extreme longevity turned out to be pretty suspect. For instance, a diet of vegetables and sweet potatoes has been identified as a potential root of Okinawa’s blue zone inhabitants. But the Japanese government has stated that Okinawans eat the lowest number of vegetables and sweet potatoes in the country, and they have the highest body mass indexes too.

Advertisement

Newman has previously debunked other claims concerning extreme age. For instance, he disproved a 2016 study that suggested a defined limit to the human lifespan. Then in 2018, he debunked another paper that made the opposite claim, showing that patterns in old-age data are probably caused by errors.

The preprint, which is a version of a paper that has not yet been peer-reviewed, is available via bioRxiv.

Deborah Bloomfield
Deborah Bloomfield

Related posts:

  1. Cricket-Manchester test likely to be postponed after India COVID-19 case
  2. EU to attend U.S. trade meeting put in doubt by French anger
  3. Soccer-West Ham win again, Leicester and Napoli falter
  4. Was Jesus A Hallucinogenic Mushroom? One Scholar Certainly Thought So

Source Link: Ig Nobel Prizewinner Debunks Supposed "Blue Zones", Where People Live Exceptionally Long Lives

Filed Under: News

Primary Sidebar

  • Purple Earth Hypothesis: Our Planet Was Not Blue And Green Over 2.4 Billion Years Ago
  • Hippos Hung Around In Europe 80,000 Years Later Than We Thought
  • Officially Gone: Slender-Billed Curlew, Once-Widespread Migratory Bird, Declared Extinct By IUCN
  • Watch: Rare Footage Captures Freaky Faceless Cusk Eels Lurking On The Deep-Sea Floor
  • Watch This Funky Sea Pig Dancing Its Way Through The Deep Sea, Over 2,300 Meters Below The Surface
  • NASA Lets YouTuber Steve Mould Test His “Weird Chain Theory” In Space
  • The Oldest Stalagmite Ever Dated Was Found In Oklahoma Rocks, Dating Back 289 Million Years
  • 2024’s Great American Eclipse Made Some Birds Behave In Surprising Ways, But Not All Were Fooled
  • “Carter Catastrophe”: The Math Equation That Predicts The End Of Humanity
  • Why Is There No Nobel Prize For Mathematics?
  • These Are The Only Animals Known To Incubate Eggs In Their Stomachs And Give “Birth” Out Their Mouths
  • Constipated? This One Fruit Could Help, Says First-Ever Evidence-Led Diet Guidance
  • NGC 2775: This Galaxy Breaks The Rules Of “Galactic Evolution” And Baffles Astronomers
  • Meet The “Four-Eyed” Hirola, The World’s Most Endangered Antelope With Fewer Than 500 Left
  • The Bizarre 1997 Experiment That Made A Frog Levitate
  • There’s A Very Good Reason Why October 1582 On Your Phone Is Missing 10 Days
  • Skynet-1A: Military Spacecraft Launched 56 Years Ago Has Been Moved By Persons Unknown
  • There’s A Simple Solution To Helping Avoid Erectile Dysfunction (But You’re Not Going To Like It)
  • Interstellar Object 3I/ATLAS May Be 10 Billion Years Old, This Rare Spider Is Half-Female, Half-Male Split Down The Middle, And Much More This Week
  • Why Do Trains Not Have Seatbelts? It’s Probably Not What You Think
  • Business
  • Health
  • News
  • Science
  • Technology
  • +1 718 874 1545
  • +91 78878 22626
  • [email protected]
Office Address
Prudour Pvt. Ltd. 420 Lexington Avenue Suite 300 New York City, NY 10170.

Powered by Prudour Network

Copyrights © 2025 · Medical Market Report. All Rights Reserved.

Go to mobile version