• Email Us: [email protected]
  • Contact Us: +1 718 874 1545
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Medical Market Report

  • Home
  • All Reports
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Spock Officially Homeless As A Further Study Disproves Planet In 40 Eridani A System

May 29, 2024 by Deborah Bloomfield

The planet confusingly known as 40 Eridani Ab has been confirmed not to exist. After previous studies had raised questions about whether activity on the star 40 Eridani A had been misinterpreted as the influence of a planet, a new paper provides proof. Under ordinary circumstances, this might be of interest only to specialists, but this faint star system has a towering role in fiction as the home system of the Vulcans, including Dr Spock. On the plus side, the methods used take us closer to finding real planets, including those in habitable zones.

Advertisement

The star 40 Eridani A is visible to the naked eye away from city lights, but only barely. The first sign it was special came with the discovery of two companions, Eridani B and C, which orbit each other every 230 years, while both being in an 8,000-year orbit around Eridani A. In 1910, Eridani B was the first star to be identified as a white dwarf. Although not the closest star of this type, it remains the easiest to see.

Advertisement

These intriguing aspects, and the fact the system is only 16 light years away, led to the system being designated as the location of planet Vulcan in the Star Trek Universe. Although life would almost certainly be impossible for a planet orbiting Eridani B or C, Eridani A looks like a good candidate for a host star. It’s quite old and fainter than the Sun, but not so faint as to make its habitable zone dangerously exposed to stellar flares as occurs for red dwarfs. The companion stars are distant enough not to pose much danger, both would be fainter than our Moon, for example.

All this background meant that reports in 2018 of a suspected planet orbiting 40 Eridani A caused unusual excitement. It was promptly named Vulcan. However, even the initial study admitted to doubts – and these were reinforced last year. Now, the final nail has been put in Vulcan’s coffin, with a paper literally titled “The Death of Vulcan.”

Initial reports of Vulcan didn’t use the method by which we have found the majority of planets so far – dips in their light as the planet obscures part of the star. Instead, astronomers were using the radial velocity method, by which most of the early planetary discoveries were made, and still favored for nearby systems. In these cases, the gravity of the planet pulls the star towards Earth and then away from us, creating blue and red shift.

When a planet’s gravity is small, the change in radial velocity can be tiny, and easily mimicked by the behavior of the star itself.

Advertisement

Dartmouth College graduate student Abigail Burrows and colleagues tested the movement of specific emission lines in 40 Eridani A’s spectrum, comparing these with the overall average. If the variation astronomers had detected was coming from a planet these should all be changing in sync. The team found they weren’t, with some lines moving on different timescales from others.

40 Eridani A has a 39-45-day rotation period – about 60 percent longer than our Sun’s. The similarity of this period to the length of the proposed planet’s 42.4-day orbit was one of the things that raised doubts initially, and Burrow’s technique suggests the variations are almost certainly rotation-related. Most likely a combination of starspots and convection within the star is causing the apparent signal.

Don’t be too sad for planet Vulcan, however. Like the proposed planet in our own system, it orbited far too close to its star to be habitable by microbes, let alone intelligent beings, logical or otherwise. 

It’s still possible there is a planet orbiting 40 Eridani A further out, including within the system’s habitable zone. The more distant a planet’s orbit, the harder it is to detect through the radial velocity method, particularly if it has a gravity more like Earth’s than Jupiter’s. A five to 10-fold increase in precision is needed if we want to use this method to find planets like the Earth in nearby stars’ habitable zones.

Advertisement

The greater capacity to distinguish between planetary effects and internal stellar behavior Burrows demonstrated means that if there is a planet in 40 Eridani A’s habitable zone we’re now closer to being able to detect it.

If that happens, however, we might need a new name – surely two failed Vulcans are enough.

(Note: Stars in multiple systems are designated with capital letters, starting with A for the brightest. Planets have small letters, and start with b. If a planet only orbits one star, rather than having a Tatooine-like orbit around both, it uses the capital of the star it orbits, followed by its order of discovery – thus 40 Eridani Ab. You can see why nicknames like Vulcan are popular).

The study is open access in The Astronomical Journal.

Deborah Bloomfield
Deborah Bloomfield

Related posts:

  1. Cricket-NZ players reach Dubai after ‘specific, credible threat’ derailed Pakistan tour
  2. Soccer-Liverpool’s Alexander-Arnold ruled out of Man City game
  3. What Are Baby Platypuses Called?
  4. Should You Wash Chicken Before Cooking It?

Source Link: Spock Officially Homeless As A Further Study Disproves Planet In 40 Eridani A System

Filed Under: News

Primary Sidebar

  • Project Hail Mary Trailer First Look: What Would Happen If The Sun Got Darker?
  • Newly Discovered Cell Structure Might Hold Key To Understanding Devastating Genetic Disorders
  • What Is Kakeya’s Needle Problem, And Why Do We Want To Solve It?
  • “I Wasn’t Prepared For The Sheer Number Of Them”: Cave Of Mummified Never-Before-Seen Eyeless Invertebrates Amazes Scientists
  • Asteroid Day At 10: How The World Is More Prepared Than Ever To Face Celestial Threats
  • What Happened When A New Zealand Man Fell Butt-First Onto A Powerful Air Hose
  • Ancient DNA Confirms Women’s Unexpected Status In One Of The Oldest Known Neolithic Settlements
  • Earth’s Weather Satellites Catch Cloud Changes… On Venus
  • Scientists Find Common Factors In People Who Have “Out-Of-Body” Experiences
  • Shocking Photos Reveal Extent Of Overfishing’s Impact On “Shrinking” Cod
  • Direct Fusion Drive Could Take Us To Sedna During Its Closest Approach In 11,000 Years
  • Earth’s Energy Imbalance Is More Than Double What It Should Be – And We Don’t Know Why
  • We May Have Misjudged A Fundamental Fact About The Cambrian Explosion
  • The Shoebill Is A Bird So Bizarre That Some People Don’t Even Believe It’s Real
  • Colossal’s “Dire Wolves” Are Now 6 Months Old – And They’ve Doubled In Size
  • How To Fake A Fossil: Find Out More In Issue 36 Of CURIOUS – Out Now
  • Is It True Earth Used To Take 420 Days To Orbit The Sun?
  • One Of The Ocean’s “Most Valuable Habitats” Grows The Only Flowers Known To Bloom In Seawater
  • World’s Largest Digital Camera Snaps 2,104 New Asteroids In 10 Hours, Mice With 2 Dads Father Their Own Offspring, And Much More This Week
  • Simplest Explanation For “Anomalous” Signals Coming From Underneath Antarctica Ruled Out
  • Business
  • Health
  • News
  • Science
  • Technology
  • +1 718 874 1545
  • +91 78878 22626
  • [email protected]
Office Address
Prudour Pvt. Ltd. 420 Lexington Avenue Suite 300 New York City, NY 10170.

Powered by Prudour Network

Copyrights © 2025 · Medical Market Report. All Rights Reserved.

Go to mobile version