• Email Us: [email protected]
  • Contact Us: +1 718 874 1545
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Medical Market Report

  • Home
  • All Reports
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Would The Titanic Have Sunk If It Hit The Iceberg Head-On?

August 1, 2024 by Deborah Bloomfield

The “unsinkable ship” known as the Titanic became arguably the most infamous shipwreck in history in 1912 after it struck an iceberg. After warnings were ignored, it wasn’t until a lookout spotted the iceberg that evasive action was taken, but it was too late.

Advertisement

The ship’s starboard side was punctured, allowing five of 16 compartments to flood with water – one more than the ship was equipped to handle – but could things have been different if no action had been taken? Would the Titanic have sunk if it hit the iceberg head-on?



 

The Titanic’s Break-Up

One of the accolades that earned the Titanic its “unsinkable” status was the inclusion of 16 compartments in the hull that were believed to be watertight. Even if flooded, it was thought that the ship could remain functional if no more than four of them filled with water. Unfortunately, when the Titanic struck the iceberg, it seems water got into five of them.

This has often been quoted as the leading cause of the Titanic sinking, though a review marking the 100th Anniversary in 2012 concluded that identifying a single cause is complex. That’s because several things went wrong after the collision, like buckling of the ship’s bottom and failure of the joints due to stress.

Avoiding The Iceberg

There are several reports of other boats at sea trying to warn the Titanic of ice up ahead, but it seems that these were ignored as ice wasn’t considered a significant threat to massive ships. That meant that by the time lookout Frederick Fleet spotted the massive iceberg directly ahead, efforts to steer around it failed to avoid a collision and the starboard side was hit and the hull buckled, allowing water to rush into the compartments.

Advertisement

As five of the compartments were breached, the ship took on water, sinking the bow and causing the stern to rise into the air. Eventually, the ship snapped in two and the bow was fully submerged, meanwhile, air trapped in the stern saw it become vertically raised before sinking into the depths.



Hitting The Iceberg Head On

The SS Arizona was a 450-foot long ship that in 1879 hit an iceberg stem-on and sailed to tell the tale for another 50 years. Another ship, the SS Grampian, also survived a head-on collision in 1919. The two vessels by no means came out unscathed, both taking on serious damage and the SS Grampian lost two stewards, but the ships themselves didn’t sink.

So, had the Titanic taken the damage head-on rather than down its starboard side, could it too have stayed afloat? According to the YouTube channel Oceanliner Designs, the complex honeycomb structure of steel in the ship’s stern means it theoretically could’ve had enough elasticity to suffer the blow without instantly breaking apart.

Advertisement

The folding in that occurs when a ship hits a stationary object head-on like this is called telescoping, and in history, it’s happened to numerous ships without them sinking. Certainly, the view that Titanic could’ve stayed afloat with a head-on collision is one that was shared by Edward Wilding, deputy to Thomas Andrews in the ship’s design department.

Excerpt from the British Wreck Commissioner’s Inquiry, Day 19

The Commissioner: Do you mean to say that if this ship had driven on to the iceberg stem on she would have been saved?
Edward Wilding: I am quite sure she would, My Lord. I am afraid she would have killed every firemen down in the firemen’s quarters, but I feel sure the ship would have come in.
 C: And the passengers would not have been lost?
EW: The passengers would have come in.
 […]
 C: Do you think that if the helm had not been starboarded there would have been a chance of the ship being saved?
EW: I believe the ship would have been saved, and I am strengthened in that belief by the case which your Lordship will remember where one large North Atlantic steamer, some 34 years ago, did go stem on into an iceberg and did come into port, and she was going fast.
Mr. Laing: The “Arizona” – I remember it.



Advertisement

According to Wilding’s testimony, the Titanic would have crumpled, killing many workers in the affected part of the ship as it was crushed 24 to 30 meters (80 to 100 feet) into the bows, but she could have stayed afloat. Of course, to expect the ship’s captain to make such a call in the face of an oncoming iceberg the size of a city block wouldn’t be reasonable, but it raises interesting ideas about the design of such enormous vessels.

Furthermore, coming to an abrupt stop when ramming into the side of an enormous iceberg comes with its own fatal consequences. As the 100th-anniversary review concluded, it’s difficult to know what could have been given the complexity of the ship’s design and how the ship could have responded to such an impact, and the possible outcome of a head-on collision becomes even more murky when you take into account the fire theory.

Deborah Bloomfield
Deborah Bloomfield

Related posts:

  1. Bolivian president calls for global debt relief for poor countries
  2. Five Seasons Ventures pulls in €180M fund to tackle human health and climate via FoodTech
  3. Humanity’s Journey To A Metal-Rich Asteroid Launches Today. Here’s How To Watch
  4. Ancient DNA Reveals People Caught Leprosy From Adorable Woodland Critters In Medieval England

Source Link: Would The Titanic Have Sunk If It Hit The Iceberg Head-On?

Filed Under: News

Primary Sidebar

  • What NASA’s Galileo Spacecraft Saw As It Plunged Into Jupiter
  • Very Hungry “Plastivore” Caterpillars Get Fat From Eating Plastic
  • “Nobody Expected This”: Earth’s Rotation Will Speed Up Tomorrow, Bucking The Downward Trend
  • Chimps Are Sticking Grass In Their Ears And Rears As They Embrace “Pointless” Fad
  • Hui Te Rangiora: Old Māori Legend Suggests They May Have Discovered Antarctica 1,000 Years Before Europeans
  • “Potential Impact On Saturn”: Astronomers Appeal For Help As Video Appears To Show Object Hitting The Gas Giant
  • What Is Prosopometamorphopsia? The “Exceedingly Rare” Condition That Made A Patient See Faces As Dragons
  • Are We In An Enormous Void? It Could Explain What’s Wrong With Our Model Of The Universe
  • Woylies Boing Back Into Western Australia Thanks To Groundbreaking Wildlife Project
  • North America’s Oldest Pterosaur And Turtle Fossils Found In Arizona’s Petrified Forest
  • Proposed “Dark Dwarfs” Near The Galactic Center Could Reveal The Nature Of Dark Matter
  • Watch: 18-Kilometer-High Ash Cloud Looms Over Indonesia’s Mount Lewotobi Laki Laki After “Explosive” Eruption
  • “ShipGoo001”: Mystery Of Entirely New Lifeform Discovered Coating A Great Lakes Ship
  • Rare White Humpback Whale Calf Filmed By Drone Off Australia’s East Coast
  • Who Was Buried At Cave Of Salome: A Female Disciple, Jesus’ Midwife, Or A Princess?
  • “Hidden” Changes To US Health Data Swapping “Gender” For “Sex” Spark Fears For Public Trust
  • Easter Island Was Never As Isolated As We Thought – Study Puts That “Strange Argument” To Bed
  • If Birds Are Dinosaurs, Why Are None As Big As T. Rexes?
  • Psychologists Demonstrate Illusion That Could Be Screwing Up Our Perception Of Time
  • Why Are So Many Enormous Roman Shoes Being Discovered At Hadrian’s Wall?
  • Business
  • Health
  • News
  • Science
  • Technology
  • +1 718 874 1545
  • +91 78878 22626
  • [email protected]
Office Address
Prudour Pvt. Ltd. 420 Lexington Avenue Suite 300 New York City, NY 10170.

Powered by Prudour Network

Copyrights © 2025 · Medical Market Report. All Rights Reserved.

Go to mobile version