• Email Us: [email protected]
  • Contact Us: +1 718 874 1545
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Medical Market Report

  • Home
  • All Reports
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

The Latest Idea For Deflecting Threatening Asteroids? X-Ray Pulses

September 23, 2024 by Deborah Bloomfield

A high-powered pulse of X-rays could vaporize part of an incoming asteroid and change its trajectory in the process, a new study proposes. Whether the approach would be more cost-effective than alternatives under consideration remains to be seen, but questions also need to be asked about the safety of building a suitable instrument in the first place. Meanwhile testing has been done on a safer scale.

Advertisement

The DART mission proved the potential for deflecting an asteroid on the path to Earth. However, questions remain whether this is the best way to deal with future such threats. Scientists at Sandia National Laboratories tested an alternative on a very small scale by firing X-ray pulses at the surface of two model asteroids in a vacuum.

The pseudo-asteroids in question were just 12mm (0.5 inches) wide. If something that size was heading for Earth it would make an eye-catching meteor, but would burn up long before reaching the ground. However, the new work proved the principle that by vaporizing two of the more common minerals in asteroids it is possible to change the momentum of the object as a whole. Scaled up, the approach could shift an asteroid sideways so that it slides past Earth, rather than making a direct hit.

Sooner or later the Earth will face an encounter with an object large enough to do us serious damage. A great many ideas have been proposed for how to deal with such a threat beyond Hollywood’s favorite “blow the damn thing up” approach. Most acknowledge it’s almost certainly more practical to change a space object’s orbit rather than destroy it entirely.

There’s a clue about how to do that in the natural behavior of comets. As sunlight heats a comet’s ice until some turns to gas, the molecules escape, forming a tail. As Newton’s third law predicts, the acceleration of the gases away from the comet applies a force to the nucleus, which can be enough to detectably change its path.

If we can replicate the effect on a threatening object, and carefully target where vaporization occurs, we can shift orbits in the desired direction.

Advertisement

Of course, turning rock to gas is a lot harder than doing the same to ice. Some proposals involve focusing lasers on the incoming threat, but X-rays carry far more energy per photon than visible light.

Using the largest pulsed power device in the world today, known as Z, Scania researchers produced shockwaves in argon gas to create a 1.5 Mega Joule X-ray pulse directed at model asteroids suspended in a vacuum. The pulse made the “asteroids”, one made of quartz, the other of fused silica, heat up so much each released a cloud of vapor, creating a shockwave that pushed at the object it came from.

Despite the differences in their composition, both “asteroids” were accelerated to almost identical speeds, 69.5 and 70.3 m/s (156 mph and 158 mph) respectively. Both figures easily exceeded expectations. 

Making something that small move, even at the speed of a bullet train, might not seem a major achievement, but the authors calculate it can be scaled up to work for objects 4 kilometers (2.5 miles) wide. That’s not quite a dino-killer, but probably large enough to end civilization.

Advertisement

The DART mission provides a hint to the viability of the idea. Dimorphos’s orbit was changed more than expected by the impact. Physicists have calculated this is because the cloud of material ejecta transferred more momentum to the asteroid as it expanded than the spacecraft itself. (You can read an excerpt and interview with Robin Andrews, author of How To Kill An Asteroid, who was right there at mission control, in the October issue of CURIOUS)

Unfortunately, it’s a lot harder to anticipate how much force a shockwave will deliver, compared to an impacting object of known mass. That’s a problem because, unless we are willing to venture out to the asteroid belt, there is a shortage of suitable objects to use as guinea pigs for future deflections. Dimorphos was chosen for the DART mission because it not only passes conveniently close to Earth, but it orbits Didymos, making any change in path far more visible than on an object orbiting the much more distant Sun.

Unless we plan to keep hitting the same unfortunate asteroid over and over again, we need alternative test subjects to compare the effectiveness of different approaches. The demonstration that these lab “asteroids” can perform that role could be more important than the measurements obtained for this specific approach.

Nevertheless, it’s unlikely humanity would want to trust its fate to a technique that hasn’t been tested on a full-sized asteroid. If X-ray pulses are the method we choose, that means putting something in space capable of delivering the requisite dose, which might raise a few eyebrows if only part of the planet has control over which way it’s pointing.

Advertisement

The study is published in Nature Physics.

Deborah Bloomfield
Deborah Bloomfield

Related posts:

  1. Cricket-Manchester test likely to be postponed after India COVID-19 case
  2. EU to attend U.S. trade meeting put in doubt by French anger
  3. Soccer-West Ham win again, Leicester and Napoli falter
  4. Was Jesus A Hallucinogenic Mushroom? One Scholar Certainly Thought So

Source Link: The Latest Idea For Deflecting Threatening Asteroids? X-Ray Pulses

Filed Under: News

Primary Sidebar

  • How To Fake A Fossil: Find Out More In Issue 36 Of CURIOUS – Out Now
  • Is It True Earth Used To Take 420 Days To Orbit The Sun?
  • One Of The Ocean’s “Most Valuable Habitats” Grows The Only Flowers Known To Bloom In Seawater
  • World’s Largest Digital Camera Snaps 2,104 New Asteroids In 10 Hours, Mice With 2 Dads Father Their Own Offspring, And Much More This Week
  • Simplest Explanation For “Anomalous” Signals Coming From Underneath Antarctica Ruled Out
  • “Lizard Shampoo” And Pagan Texts Suggest “Dark Age” Medicine Wasn’t So Dark After All
  • Japanese Macaques May Mourn Their Dead – As Long As They’re Not Maggot-Infested
  • This Is What You’d Hear If You Listened To Voyager’s Golden Record NASA Sent To Interstellar Space
  • RFK Jr’s New Vaccine Advisors Just Recommended Fall Flu Vaccines – But There’s A Catch
  • Controversial World-First Project To Create Human DNA From Scratch Takes First Steps
  • Humans Weren’t The First Species To Travel Around The Moon. They Lost This Race To An Unexpected Animal
  • When You Hack A Shark, You’re Exploiting A Glitch Billions Of Years In The Making
  • Wellness Whales, A New Blood Type, And A DJ Set From Space
  • Hate Flying Ants? We Used To Have Ones The Size Of Hummingbirds
  • ‘Tis The Season To See Titan Cast A Shadow On Saturn – Especially If You Are In America
  • World’s Bravest Vets Put Full Metal Dental Crown On A Bear For The First Time
  • “Spider Rain”: The Bizarre Phenomenon That’ll Send Arachnophobes Into A Spin
  • Scientists Gave Mice A Human “Language Gene” And Something Curious Unfolded
  • Surveillance Of People Is More “Pervasive And Normalised” Than Previously Thought, Endangering Our Privacy
  • US Sees 90 Percent Drop In Heart Attack Deaths Over Last 50 Years
  • Business
  • Health
  • News
  • Science
  • Technology
  • +1 718 874 1545
  • +91 78878 22626
  • [email protected]
Office Address
Prudour Pvt. Ltd. 420 Lexington Avenue Suite 300 New York City, NY 10170.

Powered by Prudour Network

Copyrights © 2025 · Medical Market Report. All Rights Reserved.

Go to mobile version